Perth and Kinross Council bosses accuse SNP of having 'no evidence' for local authority shake-up


A scathing report takes aim at the Scottish Government's plans for council reform.

First Minister John Swinney in Crieff. Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire

First Minister John Swinney in Crieff. Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire

A scathing report by Perth and Kinross Council bosses has accused the SNP of having “no evidence” to back up its plans to cut the number of local authorities in Scotland.

The stinging rebuke of the Scottish Government proposals comes after a meeting with Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth followed by further engagement sessions involving representatives from Tayside’s three local authorities, alongside business and community leaders.

The report penned by Lisa Simpson, the council’s strategic lead for legal and governance services, says neither of these engagements “provided an evidence base demonstrating what is failing because of existing local authority boundaries, which services are operating at the wrong scale, or why reorganisation into six to 10 regional bodies and 120 to 160 community authorities would improve outcomes”.

SNP finance chief Jenny Gilruth

Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth. Image: Robert Perry/PA Wire

In September, First Minister John Swinney announced controversial plans for council reform, telling The Courier it could see the merging of Dundee, Angus and Perth and Kinross into one Tayside authority.

Ms Gilruth later set out further details, proposing to cut Scotland’s 32 council areas to between six and 10, supplemented by 120 to 160 smaller community bodies.

The proposals have been ill-received in Mr Swinney’s own council area of Perth and Kinross, which is led by an SNP administration.

‘Absence of a clearly evidenced problem’

The latest report from Perth and Kinross Council names chief executive Thomas Glen as the local authority’s “organisational lead” on the shake-up.

Mr Glen had previously raised concerns about the lack of clarity in the SNP’s plans in correspondence with the Scottish Government.

Those questions still appear to remain.

Perth and Kinross chief executive Thomas Glen. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson

The report states that no evidence was presented to “substantiate the proposition” that councils are “too big to be local and too small to be strategic” – a key argument in the SNP’s call for reforms.

“The fundamental question therefore remains unresolved: what problem is
structural reorganisation intended to fix?” asks the report.

“The absence of a clearly evidenced problem is particularly important because the
proposition that many unitary authorities are “too small to be strategic and too
big to be local” is not a settled conclusion.”

‘Reinforced concerns’

Ms Simpson’s report says that “far from resolving” questions, the engagement sessions “reinforced concerns” about the basis and direction of the process and generated “significant constructive challenge” from those in attendance.

The Scottish Government was accused of being “wrongly focused” in regards to what the meetings should have been about.

“The format and content of the session did not allow for the open and honest two-way
dialogue required to make the engagement meaningful,” writes Ms Simpson.

First Minister John Swinney and Deputy First Minister of Scotland Jenny Gilruth. Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire

The report says attendees were left “frustrated” and with the belief that local government input was not “adequately recognised or valued”.

Perth and Kinross Council’s political group leaders have since written jointly to the Scottish Government, formally recording their disappointment and concerns in relation to the session and the wider engagement process.

The report, which will go before elected members at a special meeting of council on Monday, also asks them to reaffirm their previously agreed positions on reforms, including opposition to greater centralisation.

‘A key role to play’

The Scottish Government called Ms Gilruth’s meeting with Perth and Kinross councillors “positive and collaborative”.

A spokesperson said: “Local Government have a key role to play in public service reform.

“The Scottish Government’s commitment to reform is about delivering excellent public services that are fiscally sustainable and empower local communities.

“We are having extensive engagement with COSLA as the representative body for local government, and that has included us putting forward more detailed proposals at their request.

“The initial three-month debate and discussion period is well underway with a range of partners, including councils and across parliament, to inform the next steps.”

Conversation

Comments are currently disabled as they require cookies and it appears you've opted out of cookies on this site. To participate in the conversation, please adjust your cookie preferences in order to enable comments.