NHS Tayside fined £70k for failings that led to woman's death at Perth hospital dementia ward


The health board was sentenced on Monday after pleading guilty to health and safety shortcomings that led to the death of Andrea Imrie, 82.

Murray Royal Hospital in Perth.

Murray Royal Hospital in Perth. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson.

NHS Tayside has been fined £70,000 after admitting a series of safety failings that led to the death of a high risk dementia patient at a Perth hospital.

Andrea Imrie, 82, suffered fatal injuries in a fall while staying at Murray Royal Hospital’s Tummel Ward in January 2024.

The local health authority last month accepted criminal responsibility for the pensioner’s death.

Ms Imrie had been assessed as a “high falls risk” when she was staying at the 12-bed facility which provides treatment and assessment for over 65s with dementia.

The court heard how:

  • Hours before Ms Imrie died, staff gave her bed pad alarm to another patient, meaning the pressure sensor did not activate when she got up on her own in the early hours of the morning;
  • There were not enough of such alarms to share among all of the ward’s patients;
  • A “notoriously temperamental” motion sensor failed to activate and alert staff when Ms Imrie got out of bed.

Staff found Ms Imrie lying on the floor of her room with blood coming from her head.

A CT scan revealed she had suffered a “large volume” haemorrhage and she died days later.

Sentencing hearing

At Monday’s sentencing hearing, Sheriff Jennifer Bain fined NHS Tayside £70,000.

”I recognise there is no sentence that the court could impose which would properly reflect the value of the life lost,” she said.

”Nor will at sentence alleviate the profound upset and enduring grief that the loss of Ms Imrie’s life will have had on those loved ones left behind.”

The sheriff passed on her condolences to family members in the public gallery.

Also present in court was Zoe Robertson, newly appointed chief officer at Perth and Kinross Health and Social Care Partnership.

The sheriff said mistakes made led to Ms Imrie’s “catastrophic” injuries but noted the “comprehensive steps” NHS Tayside had since taken.

“It is hoped that the result of the implementation of these measures will mean no one else will suffer as Ms Imrie and her family have.”

She said, based on a financial assessment of the accused organisation, she initially considered imposing a penalty of between £300,000 and £1.5 million.

But the sheriff took into account that NHS Tayside’s annual budget of £1.2 billion was already set to support about 400,000 members of the public, with “significant operating deficit and no reserves.”

Sheriff Bain said the health board, which she noted was not a business looking to make a profit, would have been fined £105,000 but for its early plea, which helped avoid a lengthy and complex trial.

The trust will further have to pay a £5,520 victim surcharge.

The organisation, listed on court papers as Tayside Health Board, pled guilty to a criminal breach of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.

It follows a previous conviction from 2020 after bosses admitted a catalogue of failings that led to three suicides at the same hospital.

For that, the health board was fined £120,000.

The sheriff said this single previous conviction was the main aggravating factor.

Members of Ms Imrie’s family declined to comment following the hearing.

Murray Royal Hospital in Perth, which is operated by NHS Tayside. Image: DC Thomson.

Murray Royal Hospital in Perth. Image: DC Thomson.

The court previously heard Ms Imrie had been admitted to the Tummel Ward to be assessed for dementia in December 2023.

At around 3.30am on January 6 2024, staff became aware of a knocking sound coming from her room.

They saw Ms Imrie standing up, behind her door.

Prosecutor Lisa Duffus said: “This gave staff cause for concern as her room alarm had not been activated.”

As staff entered her room, they heard Ms Imrie fall to the ground.

First aid was provided before an ambulance transferred her to Ninewells.

“Her condition deteriorated significantly and it became apparent her life could not be saved,” said Duffus.

She received palliative care and died on January 13.

Investigation

The Health and Safety Executive carried out an immediate investigation.

It found, the day before Ms Imrie’s fall, another patient was moved onto the ward.

This new admission was also assessed as a high falls risk and was known to “self-mobilise frequently” throughout the night.

“Due to shortages, there was no available bed pad alarm for this patient,” said Ms Duffus.

It was thought it would be safe to give the new patient Ms Imrie’s alarm because she was more “settled”.

“Staff would not have made this decision if NHS Tayside had ensured there were enough alarms available,” Ms Duffus said.

Perth Sheriff Court

Perth Sheriff Court.

The court also heard Ms Imrie’s motion sensor had been checked by a nurse on January 5, the day of the fall.

This member of staff went off duty at 3pm.

“Staff reported that these alarms were notoriously temperamental and that the location of the bed was critical to their operation.”

A photo taken by police after Ms Imrie’s fall showed the room’s motion sensor was damaged.

Ms Duffus said since the tragedy, every room now has a bed pad alarm and motion sensors are checked just before patients’ bed times.

Defence counsel Peter Gray KC stressed the failings were “not in any sense deliberate and were isolated failings in the management of risks”.

He said NHS Tayside had since taken steps to prevent any repeat of the tragedy.

Every room now has a bed pad alarm and motion sensors are checked just before patients’ bed times.

Crown Office statement

Debbie Carroll, who leads on health and safety investigations for the Crown, said:  ”This was the tragic death of a vulnerable patient whose care plan identified clear measures to reduce the risk of a fall.

“Those measures were not fully in place. One alarm had been removed because of equipment shortages and another failed to operate when it was needed.

“Organisations responsible for the care of vulnerable people must ensure that risk control measures are available, maintained and working effectively at all times.

“While no prosecution can undo the consequences of this tragic incident, we hope this action highlights the serious consequences that can follow when health and safety systems fall short of the standards required.”

For more local court content visit our page or join us on Facebook.