Crieff Drummond Arms housing plan faces axe as council admits £18m funding gap


Perth and Kinross Council says plans to build affordable housing on the site of the derelict Drummond Arms Hotel in Crieff are no longer viable.

Drummond Arms Hotel exterior with scaffolding outside

The saga of Crieff's Drummond Arm Hotel has taken another twist. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson

Perth and Kinross Council chiefs are set to abandon a controversial plan to demolish Crieff’s crumbling Drummond Arms Hotel and build affordable housing in its place.

Officers say there is now “no reasonable prospect of delivering a viable affordable housing scheme” on the site.

And they want approval to consider alternative uses for the town centre eyesore.

The council took ownership of the B-listed landmark in 2024 after a Crieff community bid to restore it ran out of time and money.

Councillors later approved a £3 million plan to demolish the 19th century building so flats could be built there instead.

However, the proposal sparked widespread opposition in Crieff.

And councillors are now being asked to call a halt to the housing project next week.

It comes after Historic Environment Scotland (HES) said repeatedly it would block the demolition.

Drummond Arms hotel interior showing missing floor, bared walls and piles of debris

Once the pride of Crieff, the Drummond Arms Hotel is in a sorry state. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson

A report to Wednesday’s meeting of the council’s finance and resources committee says the two compromise options on the table would cost between £22-25 million to construct.

These would allow 19 one and two-bedroom flats to be constructed, while retaining the building’s facade.

Both would leave the council with a funding gap of more than £18m.

And neither would be enough to satisfy Historic Environment Scotland.

The agency said the decision to demolish a listed building must always be a last resort.

And in the case of the Drummond Arms, it said: “It remains unclear that all reasonable efforts have been made to retain the building given its special interest.”

Crieff community favour ‘open space’ for Drummond Arms Hotel site

The committee report says: “The work undertaken to date demonstrates that affordable housing on the Drummond Arms site is not financially viable within the funding identified, whether through façade retention or demolition and new build.

“It is therefore recommended that the Finance and Resources Committee agree that
affordable housing should no longer be pursued.”

Weeds sprout from the roof of boarded-up Drummond Arms in Crieff

Weeds sprout from the roof of the boarded-up Drummond Arms Hotel in Crieff town centre. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson

If councillors back that recommendation, officers want permission to “assess alternative uses, alongside proposals for other Crieff sites, including the former Crieff Primary School”.

The council previously revealed plans for up to 30 affordable homes on the Commissioner Street school site.

Crieff residents who attended a meeting with the council last month suggested a community-led “civic open space” for The Drummond Arms Hotel site.

However, the officers’ report warns the way ahead is by no means clear.

Former Crieff Primary School exterior

The fate of the old Crieff Primary School is also up for debate. Image: Google Maps

“Any preferred proposal will require a deliverable funding and maintenance
plan and the necessary statutory consents,” it says.

“Historic Environment Scotland’s objection to demolition remains unresolved.”

Sad decline of Crieff landmark

It’s the latest twist in a lengthy saga around the fate of the Drummond Arms.

The landmark has long been one of Crieff’s most prominent buildings, sitting in the centre of the High Street across from James Square.

Bonnie Prince Charlie famously held his last council of war before Culloden on the site.

However, the hotel ceased trading in 2006 and the vacant property has fallen further and further into disrepair.

Painting of Bonnie Prince Charlie on floor surrounded by debris beside rotting staircase

A nod to the Drummond Arms’ history inside the derelict Crieff hotel. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson

Crieff Community Trust (CCT) acquired it through a Community Right to Buy in 2014.

It established Drummond Arms Regeneration Limited (DARL) in 2019 with the goal of refurbishing and regenerating the building.

However, it could not raise the necessary funds and the company was wound up in March 2025.

The hotel was served with a Dangerous Building Notice in October 2024, shortly before the council took ownership.

The first phase of demolition was completed last November.

It included the removal of outbuildings and works to stabilise the chimneys, wall heads and gables of the main building.

The report to next week’s committee says: “There is ongoing surveillance of the building particularly after any severe weather events, as whilst the works are completed, the building continues to be in a precarious state.”

The council has spent around £1m of its £3m budget so far.