Perth council teams tackle 'extraordinary' rise in AI requests with printouts and highlighter pens


Perth and Kinross councillors were told staff are being bombarded with AI-generated 'jibberish' from 'people who are angry with life and looking for someone to blame'

Perth and Kinross Council HQ exterior

AI is fuelling a huge increase in requests and complaints to Perth and Kinross Council. Image: DC Thomson

A council boss has confessed teams are printing out AI-generated requests from the public and going through them with highlighter pens to try to understand them.

Data protection officer Jillian Walker made the admission during a Perth and Kinross Council meeting after telling councillors artificial intelligence is helping to fuel an “extraordinary” rise in correspondence.

The scrutiny and performance committee heard complaints, data compliance and Freedom of Information requests are all rocketing.

And officers say AI is contributing to both the volume and complexity of dealing with them.

Councillors were told staff are often “wading through jibberish” to try to get to the point of genuine requests.

One asked Ms Walker if the council could use its own AI tools to sift through AI-generated messages.

She said the solution was, so far, proving even simpler.

Woman uses an orange highlighter to review printed paperwork beside a laptop and notebook, with a softly blurred evening city view in the background

Perth and Kinross Council staff are taking a low-tech approach to AI-generated inquiries. Image: Shutterstock

“The thing that we’ve actually found most useful for getting to the nub of the matter has been to print out requests and go through them with a highlighter pen,” she said.

“It sounds very low-tech. But quite a lot of what is generated in these requests may be nonsensical.

“We have had more than one occasion when we’ve gone back to people with the information and they’ve said ‘oh I didn’t ask for this’ and we’ve said ‘yes you did’, and they’ve been unaware of the question.”

AI fuelling ‘extraordinary’ rise in requests for Perth and Kinross Council date

Ms Walker said “subject access requests” alone had risen by 100% in the last two years, partly due to AI.

UK GDPR rules and the Data Protection Act 2018 give people the right to ask organisations for any personal data which they may be holding.

Much of the increase is also connected to the Scotland’s Redress Scheme.

It provides financial payments, emotional support, and official apologies to people who suffered historical child abuse in care settings.

Perth and Kinross Council logo on wall of council HQ in Perth

Members of the public are also using AI to make requests to Perth and Kinross Council under Scotland’s Redress Scheme. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson

“The growth in the amount of work associated with this has been extraordinary,” she said.

“And that’s not a word I’m using lightly.”

Ms Walker said council staff dealing with these requests might be processing “thousands of pages of highly distressing records and corresponding with requesters in a really compassionate, trauma-informed sensitive way”.

Despite the pressures, she said compliance with subject access requests increased in the past year.

However, she said this was unlikely to continue due to the rising workload.

‘Don’t use AI’, pleads Perth and Kinross Council legal chief

The council’s head of legal and governance Lisa Simpson also addressed the committee on the challenges presented by artificial intelligence.

“AI means people can produce 10, 11, 12 page requests at the flick of a button,” she said.

“And we know when we get it that 80% of it will be nonsensical”.

Lisa Simpson smiling

Perth and Kinross Council legal chief Lisa Simpson discussed the challenges posed by AI. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson

She said many requests were genuine.

But she said there was also a section of society who are “angry with life, looking for somebody to blame and bombarding the council with either complaints, access requests and Freedom of Information requests”.

The most abusive complaints and requests are passed to Police Scotland.

But Ms Simpson said the best advice she could offer members of the public is “don’t use AI if you genuinely want information”.

“Tell us what you want and we will try our best to find that,” she said.

“If you want to access your information that’s held by the council, let us know the information you are looking for and we will find it for you.

“But there’s an awful lot of time and resources being taken up by basically wading through jibberish.”