John Swinney was privately warned THREE times about NHS Grampian 'avoidable deaths'


The first minister faced an angry backlash after a senior Aberdeen Royal Infirmary surgeon finally gave up waiting for a response to serious allegations.

Dr Mohammed Habib spoke out on Thursday. Image: PA

Dr Mohammed Habib spoke out on Thursday. Image: PA

John Swinney was accused of ignoring multiple chances to address avoidable deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary on the day a surgeon leaked a “buried” NHS Grampian report.

The first minister was told three times in emails by whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib about concerns of high death rates after operations.

The doctor also contacted other government ministers, according to emails dating back more than three years, all released on Thursday morning.

The correspondence lifts the lid on attempts by the experience surgeon to get someone in power to take notice.

Instead, civil servants passed Dr Habib onto other institutions where he failed to get answers.

The surgeon went public in an astonishingly detailed press conference in Glasgow on Thursday morning.

John Swinney, standing next to former health secretary Neil Gray. Image: Andrew MacColl/Shutterstock

Among the evidence were multiple emails and an internal report by NHS Grampian, not previously made public.

It showed 19 deaths from a group of 45 were “avoidable”.

At First Minister’s Questions in Holyrood on Thursday afternoon, Mr Swinney said the revelations were of the “gravest concern”.

It comes one week after separate damning inspection reports founds serious failures in leadership across NHS Grampian, which led to senior managers losing jobs.

Mr Swinney said: “The points raised are of the deepest of concern to me. It is important that in all circumstances where concerns are raised, they are properly pursued.

“We obviously rely on health boards to undertake that responsibility because that is their statutory duty.”

Families were not told

The Scottish Government has come to the conclusion that NHS Grampian has to undertake “significant improvement”, he added.

But Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra – a North East MSP – said the details were already explained to ministers including Mr Swinney several times in writing.

“Nineteen people. Fathers, mothers, grandparents, friends, loved ones – in the care of our NHS while they were sick – died when they should not have,” Mr Marra said.

“Families were not told, the public were not told, but the first minister was told. Four times Dr Habib wrote to Scottish ministers – including three times to John Swinney – seeking help for the people in his care. Yet, nothing was done to stop the deaths.”

He demanded an immediate review to establish who knew what inside the government.

Mr Marra also wants a criminal prosecution.

“Hundreds of grieving families across the country will be wondering today if it was their son, their daughter, their mum, their dad, who died needlessly and might still be with them if only this government had listened,” he told parliament.

“They deserve answers and they deserve justice. The first minister was told and did nothing. He must act today to get answers for these families.”

Michael Marra led questions on the whistleblower scandal. Image: Darrell Benns/DC Thomson.

Timeline of emails

Dr Habib’s released communications show an email was sent to the health secretary on the 19 avoidable deaths on June 14 2023.

Another was sent to the health chief and Mr Swinney on October 7 2024, then again on November 20, with a follow up on December 3. Another email was sent on May 14 this year.

A final response in the published emails, dated June 16, from a civil servant, recognises the “seriousness” of the issues.

It confirms the government’s chief medical officer was also aware by summer.

Dr Habib was told to contact police, the General Medical Council, and follow “appropriate established escalation routes”.

After his appearance at First Minister’s Questions, Mr Swinney told journalists the letters were dealt with at official level and he only saw them for the first time on Thursday.

First minister was warned

Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay said the system is rotten.

“First Minister John Swinney was warned, personally,” he said during questions at Holyrood.

He claimed patients died and failure has been rewarded inside health boards.

“Why does he think this perverse culture is acceptable?” he asked.

Greens co-leader Gillian Mackay feared people will be put off from seeking help in hospitals.

Scottish Liberal Democrat Alex Cole-Hamilton also called for an investigation.

Have you been affected?